Great question! I've used both, and honestly, it depends on what you need-but for most DIYers, stainless steel is the way to go. Let's break it down.
First, stainless steel. The biggest win here is no rust. I leave mine in a damp toolbox sometimes (oops) and it still looks brand new. It's also super easy to clean-filler wipes off without sticking too much, and you don't have to worry about soap and water ruining it.
The only downside? It's a little less flexible than carbon steel, but for most jobs (filling holes, smoothing walls), it's totally fine. I have a stainless steel knife that I've used for 3 years-still sharp, no rust, works like a dream.
Now carbon steel. It's more flexible than stainless steel, which is great if you're working with uneven surfaces (like old wood) where you need the blade to bend a little. But here's the catch: it rusts so easily.
Even a drop of water left on the blade overnight will leave a rust spot. You also have to dry it immediately after cleaning, and sometimes even oil it to keep it from rusting.
Carbon steel is better for pros who use their knives every day and take good care of them-but for casual DIYers? Stainless steel is way more low-maintenance. I tried a carbon steel knife once, forgot to dry it, and it rusted in two days. Never again!
filling knife from hanke tools











