I remember staring at the hardware store shelf, totally overwhelmed-there were so many sizes and brands, I had no clue where to start. After asking around and trying a few, here's what I'd tell any beginner: go for a 10-inch London pattern trowel first. Let me break why that works.
First, the size: 10 inches is just right. A smaller one (like 8 inches) means you have to reload mortar more often, which slows you down and makes you more frustrated. A bigger one (12 inches) is heavy-my arm got tired after 20 minutes when I tried that. The 10-inch one balances being able to hold enough mortar without wearing you out.
Then the London pattern: the blade is a little wider at the top, which makes it easier to scoop and spread mortar evenly. I tried a Philadelphia pattern first, and the narrower blade made it hard to get a smooth layer-kept leaving gaps. Also, look for a trowel with a comfortable handle. I got a cheap one with a plastic handle once, and after an hour, my hand was sore and slippery from sweat. A rubberized or wooden handle (but make sure it's sealed so mortar doesn't soak in) is way better.
Brands? I started with a Marshalltown-they're not the cheapest, but they're durable, and the blade stays sharp longer. You don't need to drop a ton of money on a fancy one as a beginner, but avoid the $10 ones-they bend easily, and the blade will rust fast. Trust me, investing a little in a mid-range 10-inch London pattern will make your first projects way less stressful.
Brick trowel from hanke tools











