When I went to the hardware store to buy one, I stood there for 10 minutes just looking-didn't know they came in so many sizes. Turns out each size is for something different, and now I wish I'd bought two at first.
The smallest is 1 inch. I got that one for tiny jobs-like filling in the nail holes from hanging Christmas lights, or cleaning out the little gaps around light switches. If I used a bigger knife for those, I'd get spackle all over the wall around the hole. The 1-inch one's precise, so I only put spackle where I need it.
Then there's 2-inch and 3-inch. These are the ones I use most. The 2-inch is good for slightly bigger holes-like the ones from a loose shelf bracket. The 3-inch? Perfect for smoothing out larger areas of spackle, or scraping paint off baseboards. I used the 3-inch last month to scrape old paint off my porch railings-covered more area, so I finished faster.
Bigger sizes are 4-inch, 6-inch, and 8-inch. I got a 4-inch when I finished my basement. I used it to spread joint compound over the drywall seams-way faster than using the 3-inch. The 6-inch and 8-inch are for really big jobs, like smoothing an entire wall or removing wallpaper from a whole room. My neighbor used an 8-inch when he redid his living room, and he said it cut his time in half. I haven't needed that yet, but now I know it's there if I do.
soft touch putty knife











