Let's cut to the chase: the "best" material depends on what you need, but for most people-especially beginners-stainless steel is the way to go. But let's break down the three main materials you'll see (stainless steel, carbon steel, and plastic) so you can decide for yourself. I've used all three, and each has its pros and cons.
First, stainless steel. This is my go-to, and it's perfect for beginners. Why? It's durable, doesn't rust easily, and it's lighter than carbon steel. When you're learning, you don't want a heavy trowel weighing down your arm-stainless steel is easy to handle for hours. It also cleans up nicely-plaster doesn't stick to it as much as other materials. The only downside? It's a little more expensive than plastic, but it's worth it. I've had a stainless steel trowel for five years, and it still looks like new. I once left it out in the rain overnight (oops), and it didn't rust at all. That's a win.
Then, carbon steel. This is what most pros use-but it's not great for beginners. Carbon steel is stiffer than stainless steel, which means it can push plaster into the wall more easily. But it's heavier, and it rusts super easily. You have to dry it immediately after use and oil it every time, or it'll start rusting within days. I tried a carbon steel trowel when I was new, and I forgot to oil it once-by the next week, there was rust all over the blade. It still worked, but it left streaks in the plaster. Carbon steel is great if you're a pro who uses it every day and knows how to care for it, but it's too high-maintenance for beginners.
Third, plastic. This is the cheapest option, but it's not great for serious work. Plastic trowels are light, but they're flimsy-they bend easily when you push plaster, which leaves uneven layers. They also scratch easily, and once they're scratched, they're useless. I bought a plastic trowel once to save money, and it bent on the first wall I plastered. I had to stop and buy a stainless steel one halfway through. Plastic is okay if you're doing a tiny, one-time job (like patching a small hole), but don't use it for anything bigger.
So, to sum up: stainless steel is the best for most people-durable, easy to care for, and easy to handle. Carbon steel is for pros. Plastic is for emergencies only. Pick stainless steel, and you won't regret it.
plastering trowel from hanke tools











